Method

The Buyer's Eye Scorecard.

One rubric for every product, tool and service I review. Seven weighted criteria, a dated price check, and a plain answer to who should skip it. I built it from a decade of vetting suppliers for a living.

Seven criteria, weighted.

Each is scored 0 to 5. Points equal the weight times the score divided by 5, so the total is out of 100.

CriterionWeightWhat I check
Price vs. value20Current price on the brand's own page, compared with at least two real alternatives and cost per use where it applies.
Spec accuracy15Listing claims checked against the brand's own spec sheet. Mismatches are called out.
Build quality15Materials, finish and how it holds up after real use.
Ease of use15Setup, learning curve and daily friction. Could a busy person use it correctly on day one?
Real-world results15Does it do what it says in an ordinary home or business, not a demo?
Support, warranty and returns10Warranty length, return window, who pays return shipping, and how fast support answers.
Claims honesty10Marketing claims versus evidence, plus clear disclosure of how I got the product and what I earn.

Price vs. value carries the most weight because it is the question every buyer is really asking. Who should skip it is not scored. It is required on every review.

What the total means.

The verdict is the band the total falls in, in plain words.

85 to 100Buy itStrong on price, accuracy and real use. Few caveats.
70 to 84Good, with caveatsWorth it for the right person. Read who should skip it.
55 to 69SituationalFine in one specific case. Compare alternatives first.
0 to 54SkipWeak value or too many gaps between claims and reality.

Dated, then re-checked.

A score is only useful while the price and specs behind it are still true.

1

Checked on a date

Every scorecard shows the day I confirmed price and specs on the brand's own page.

2

Re-checked on a schedule

About every 90 days for evergreen reviews, and again before big sales events.

3

Re-scored on change

A price move over 10 percent, a spec change or a new version triggers an early re-score.

4

Logged in public

Each review keeps an update log, so you can see what changed and when.

What never changes a score.

Affiliate commission, a gifted product or a sponsor's request. Disclosure appears on every review.

I use the same rubric on a product a brand sent me and on one I bought with my own money. Where a brand is a paid partner, the post says so at the top.

What a scorecard looks like.

This is the block that appears in each review. The numbers below are invented to show the layout.

The Buyer's Eye Scorecard · how it works

Example: Acme Widget Pro

Prices and specs checked: Nov 14, 2026. Next re-check: Feb 2027.

CriterionWeightScorePoints
Price vs. value204 / 516 / 20
Spec accuracy155 / 515 / 15
Build quality153 / 59 / 15
Ease of use154 / 512 / 15
Real-world results154 / 512 / 15
Support, warranty and returns103 / 56 / 10
Claims honesty105 / 510 / 10

Total: 80 / 100. Verdict: Good, with caveats

Who should skip it: Anyone who needs this for daily heavy use. The example battery life will not keep up.

Example only: invented numbers that show the layout. Real scorecards carry a real update log.

Questions, answered.

What is the Buyer's Eye Scorecard?

It is the rubric I use on every product, tool and service I review. Seven weighted criteria add up to a score out of 100, each score carries the date I checked prices and specs, and every review says plainly who should skip the product.

Can a brand pay to change a score?

No. Affiliate commissions, gifted products and sponsorships do not change the rubric or the score. Every review discloses how I got the product and whether I earn from a link.

How often are scores re-checked?

Evergreen reviews are re-checked about every 90 days and again before major sales events. A price move of more than 10 percent, a spec change or a new product version triggers an earlier re-score. Each change goes in the review's update log.

Does the scorecard work for software and AI tools?

Yes. For software, price vs. value covers the plan I actually use, ease of use covers setup and daily friction, and spec accuracy covers whether features match the vendor's own documentation. Built reviews use the same seven criteria.

Why is "who should skip it" required?

A review that only says who should buy is an ad. Naming who should skip a product is how a buyer saves money, and it is the part I used to look for as a corporate buyer.

For brands

Want a product scored?

I review beauty devices, home goods and the software I use to run my businesses, always with this scorecard. Tell me about your product and I will tell you honestly whether it is a fit. I reply within 1–2 business days.

Method last updated Nov 14, 2026. See the businesses and tools it is applied to on the Built hub.